When Should You NOT Work with a Cash Buyer (Ohio Guide) 

It is a fairly regular occurrence for me to receive a call from a potential seller, gather some basic information about their home during the conversation, and quickly determine that they should not be talking to cash buyers.   

I also receive calls from potential sellers who should absolutely be considering a cash buyer as an option.   

What makes one seller a good candidate for a cash buyer when the other should be talking to a realtor and listing their home on the market?  

This article will seek to answer that question in an honest and straightforward manner.  I will try to give you a much better understanding of whether you should be calling me and other cash buyers. 

The first section below discusses when you should consider calling a cash buyer, and the second section discusses when you should not call a cash buyer.   

Table of Contents

1. When It Makes Sense to Call an Ohio Cash Buyer

  • Your property is in serious disrepair

    • A real example: a fire-damaged home in Wickliffe

  • Buyers cannot obtain financing for your home

  • You need to sell quickly

    • Why selling with a realtor takes longer

    • How long it takes to receive payment with a realtor

    • How long it takes to receive payment with a cash buyer

  • Your property has a challenging tenant

    • Why a tenant can complicate a realtor sale

    • How a cash buyer can simplify the process

  • You inherited an Ohio property and live out of state

2. When a Cash Buyer May Not Be the Right Choice

  • Your home is in great shape

    • The 20-question property condition checklist

    • Why selling with a realtor may bring a higher price

  • Your home is already listed

    • Listing agreements and realtor commissions

    • Why an overpriced home is not selling

3. Conclusion: Is a Cash Buyer Right for You?

You Should Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if You Meet These Criteria

A cash buyer is a tool you have available to you when you want to sell your property, but we are a tool you should use under the right set of circumstances.   

A call to a cash buyer is worthwhile if your property and your needs line up with any of the following real-life scenarios.  These are scenarios where I have been an appropriate solution for sellers and I purchased their home:  

You Should Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if Your Property is in Serious Disrepair

“Serious disrepair” can come in many shapes and sizes.   

It could be a house that has been saturated with dog and/or cat smells and requires specialized work and products to remove the smell (this article is about a very smelly house that I purchased).   

It could be a home where a lot of the essential equipment is broken or missing (e.g. heating and cooling systems, plumbing and water heaters, electrical failures, etc.).   

I am not describing a situation where only one or two items are broken, and the repairs are low cost.  “Serious disrepair” would mean that a large number of necessary home systems do not work.   

“Serious disrepair” could also be a house where some of the scarier big-ticket items, those that frequently cause home buyers to immediately walk away, need to be addressed.  That list would include significant problems with the foundation (i.e. bowing and/or cracked walls), a leaking roof that is past due for replacement, a basement that gets wet with every rain, and similar serious problems which carry a high repair price tag.   

The theme with houses in serious disrepair is that a large pool of normal buyers (i.e. buyers who need to use FHA or conventional financing to pay for the home and who want to live in the home after purchasing it) will (a) not be able to get bank approval for a standard loan to purchase the home and/or (b) will not be willing to take on the risk, headaches and delayed ability to move into the home.   

For the homes I describe above, the situation that arises is one where the seller only has access to a very small pool of potential buyers.  These are cash buyers who do not need a bank to approve a loan and who have no immediate need to move into the home.    

An Extreme Example of an Ohio Home in Serious Disrepair 

To give you a sense of the type of disrepair a cash buyer can take on, you can see a video here of a home in Wickliffe, OH that I purchased quickly for cash.  The story behind this home is as follows:   

A battery-operated toy in a bedroom caught fire, and the fire spread to the drapes and then throughout the bedroom.  This led to a lot of fire damage in the bedroom and adjacent hallway, but also a lot of soot and smoke which damaged drywall and surfaces throughout the entire home. 

The owners did not have insurance at the time of the fire and could not afford to repair the damage.  They had hoped they would find an alternative solution, but after time passed and a solution did not appear, they simply moved on.  

The home sat vacant for three years and, unfortunately, the long vacancy compounded the problems with the home.  The home was not properly weatherized, which led to pipes bursting, leaks, a broken water heater, a damaged furnace, and weather damage as problems with the roof were left unrepaired.  

The basement had a lot of water intrusion when it rained, and the house not only needed basement waterproofing, but half of a basement wall needed to be replaced entirely because it was bowing and shearing (coming off the bottom row of masonry) badly.   

On top of the fire damage and weather damage, the home was very dated.   

In short, this is an example of a major fixer upper, and this is a great example of a situation where it is worth calling a cash buyer.   Does your home have to be in as bad of a condition as this one to make it worthwhile to call a cash buyer?  No, not at all, but it gives an example of something on the extreme end of the “serious disrepair” spectrum.   

It is Worth Calling an Ohio Cash Buyer if Financing is Not Available for Your Home

As a general rule, if lenders (and especially an FHA lender) can determine that your home is not in a safe, habitable and insurable condition, those lenders are not going to provide buyers with financing.   

If a large group of buyers cannot obtain financing to purchase your home, calling a cash buyer makes sense because a real Ohio cash buyer does not need any lender approval for the purchase.   

To give you some specific examples in major lender guidelines, the Federal Housing Authority uses “safe, sound, and secure” in its definition of Minimum Property Requirements (MPR).   

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac say the property must be “safe, sound, and structurally secure.”

These lenders will send in appraisers and inspectors to assess your home to make sure it satisfies their criteria before they will agree to provide a buyer with a loan.

The prior section covers many of the conditions a lender would consider to be unsafe, not sound and not structurally secure.  Further below, in the section entitled, “Don’t Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if Your Home is in Great Shape” I have a list of questions that will help you determine if your home will not meet some lender criteria.  

If your home has many of the problems in that list, a cash buyer might be your best solution.   

You Should Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if You Need to Sell with Speed

As you will see below, a sale to a good Ohio cash buyer will be significantly faster than a sale using a realtor.   

Based on independent data from companies like Realtor.com, if you tried to sell your home with a realtor in March of 2026 it would have taken over 60 days on average to receive payment for your home.    

In comparison, when working with a good cash buyer you should receive payment for your Ohio property within 10-20 days.   

Where most sellers get confused is in failing to distinguish between two different time frames:  

(1) The number of days it will take you to sell your home starting from when you select a realtor or cash buyer; and  

(2) The number of days it will take to sell your Ohio home starting from when you sign the sale contract with a buyer.  

When working with a good Ohio cash buyer, both of those time frames are much faster in comparison to working with a realtor.   

Why Does it Take So Much Longer to Sell a Home with an Ohio Realtor 

In a normal home sale involving a realtor, the typical purchase contract will say that the sale will close within around 30 days from the date the contract is signed by both parties. You sometimes see contracts which say they will close within 21 days, but that is on the faster end of normal when working with a realtor.   

However, this does not mean that when you work with a realtor, it will take between 21-30 days in total to be paid for your Ohio home.  It will be much longer.    

The reason it will be much longer is simple.  

If you accept an offer from a good Ohio cash buyer, they will be able to sign a contact with you within 24-48 hours of viewing your home. 

A realtor, however, does not meet you on day 1, sign a listing agreement with you the same day, list your property when they get back to their desk the same day, and then immediately get you a signed buyer contract.  

First, the realtor will meet you at your home to get a feel for the property.  They will discuss their commission and listing process with you.  They will provide suggestions about things you can do around the property to improve it before it is listed.   

Second, if you decide to hire them, they will contact their photographer who will schedule a time to come and take pictures.   

Third, when the pictures are ready, the realtor will prepare the listing and blast it out to the internet to start the search for buyers.   

Fourth, after the listing is online, you will wait for potential buyers to schedule showings.   

Depending on (a) the time of year, (b) the weather, (c) the supply of other houses on the market, (d) the condition of your home, (e) the list price and other factors, you may or may not have many potential buyers touring your property.   

Fifth, you will wait for offers to come in after showings, and if an offer comes in after a showing and you decide to pursue it, there may be some negotiation.   

Sixth, only after any negotiations conclude and both sides accept the terms of the offer and sign the contract will the clock finally start on the typical 21-30 days to receive money for your house.   

Exactly How Long does it Take to Receive Payment When Working with an Ohio Realtor? 

So how long does it actually take from the day you hire a realtor until the day you receive money for your Ohio home?  Luckily, the real estate market is tracked so closely by big data companies that we do not have to guess.   

For example, this article by Realtor.com found that in Cleveland, OH, “The median days on market was 54 days in March 2026.”  

Those 54 days represent the amount of time after the time it took for the realtor to list the home that it took to (1) complete showings and find a buyer and (2) close on the sale of the home with that buyer.   

What this means is that on average in March 2026 you would add the time it takes to get your home listed (i.e. the time it takes to select a realtor, agree to terms for the listing, get photos completed and get the listing online and marketed) together with 54 days and that is how long it would take for you to receive money for your home.   

Even assuming a very aggressive time frame of 7 days from the day you meet with a realtor to the day the home is listed on the market, that still means that on average it would take 61 days before you receive money for your home when working with a realtor.   

Exactly How Long does it Take to Receive Payment When Working with an Ohio Cash Buyer? 

Compared to working with a realtor, the process of working with a good Ohio cash buyer is simpler and more efficient.   

A good Ohio cash buyer will: 

(1) Have an introductory phone call with you where they will ask some questions about the property;  

(2) Shortly after the call, conduct some online research about the Ohio property and then schedule a time to see it if they are interested; 

(3) Come to see the property on the appointed date and time; 

(4) Make you an offer within 24-48 hours after the property tour if they remain interested; 

(5) Sign the contract with you on the same day as their offer if you accept their terms; 

(6) Pay you for your Ohio property within 10-20 days after you accept their offer.   

In other words, it can take at least three times longer to receive payment when working with a realtor in comparison to a cash buyer.   

You Should Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if Your Property is Occupied by a Challenging Tenant 

It goes without saying that there are many wonderful tenants out there.   

However, from time-to-time Ohio property owners can find themselves with a tenant who is a real nightmare.   

They can destroy your property, steal, lie, be verbally abusive, refuse to pay rent even when you fulfill your obligations as a landlord, refuse to allow repairs or inspections, and can generally put you in a terrible situation where you have no option but to hire an attorney.   

In such circumstances, it can be a real blessing to find a skilled Ohio cash buyer who has experience with troublesome tenants and is not afraid of the legal challenges associated with them.   

If you are trying to handle a terrible tenant by yourself, I wrote an article here detailing the rules I follow when dealing with tenant occupied properties.   

Why is it Difficult to Use a Realtor when Selling an Ohio Home Occupied by a Challenging Tenant?   

It is not in a difficult tenant’s interest to support a sale of your Ohio property, particularly when they have not been paying all their rent.     

Difficult tenants will therefore resist realtor requests to get into the house.   

They will often tell realtors that they will allow a showing at an agreed time and then either (a) change their mind at the last minute and refuse access or (b) refuse to open the door when the potential buyer shows up for their scheduled tour.   

Difficult tenants frequently reject or deliberately avoid answering calls that they know are coming from their landlord’s realtor.   

Difficult tenants will also fail to make the home look clean and tidy before potential buyers show up.  They will also sometimes act especially troublesome to deter buyers.   

Realtors will often stop making a significant effort in such situations because they have other listings that require much less work and fewer headaches.   

Realtors will also sometimes push a lot of the heavy lifting on to the seller in terms of tenant communication, tenant coordination, and providing access to such properties.   The problem with that approach is that the tenant and seller are often on very bad terms, making it incredibly challenging to navigate a sale process that depends on the tenant being cooperative.  

Why is it Easier to Use a Cash Buyer when Selling an Ohio Home Occupied by a Challenging Tenant?   

A good Ohio cash buyer will not require a seller to continue to shoulder the burden of dealing with a difficult tenant.   

They will make their best effort to gain access to the property to check its condition.   

After doing that, a good cash buyer will make a prompt cash offer that accounts for the challenges and costs that the difficult tenant presents.   

That fast and practical approach gives the seller an option to quickly rid themselves of the tenant burden.      

You Should Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if You Inherited an Ohio Property and Live Out of State 

Last year I purchased a property from a seller who lives in Kentucky.  The home had belonged to her mother, and she was in the process of moving her mother to Kentucky so they could be closer.     

This dynamic is very common, and it presents some challenges for a seller when working with a realtor: 

(1) When you live out of state, it is hard to coordinate removing furniture and other belongings from a house to make it ready for realtor showings.   

In this particular case, the seller was taking multiple trips from Kentucky to try to get things ready for the sale process.  That was a time and labor-intensive process with multiple headaches involved.   

(2) Realtors will sometimes make recommendations for changes to the home (repairs, painting, cleaning, etc.).   

Trying to manage such tasks from a long distance is a recipe for (a) poor work quality if it is not being closely monitored, (b) being overcharged by contractors who the seller never meets in person to assess their integrity, and (c) headaches in terms of timing, providing access, and verifying completion.   

(3) A seller can ask a realtor to manage all the above-described tasks, but many realtors will not be so hands on.   

(4) If you are not local, even small issues can become slow and expensive to manage.   

In contrast, a good Ohio cash buyer will address all these problems because: 

(1) Good cash buyers do not care if the seller’s unwanted belongings remain in a property.  They will offer to take on the burden of removing any items the seller does not want to remove.    

(2) Good cash buyers also do not require repairs, cleaning, painting, or any other changes to the property, so the seller will not be required to manage any related tasks.  

(3) In short, a seller will not need to coordinate anything beyond (a) the initial call with the cash buyer and (b) allowing the buyer into the home one time so they can assess the property’s condition.   

Beyond that, if the seller likes the cash buyer’s offer, the seller can sell the home without additional work or headaches.   

You Should Not Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if You Meet These Criteria 

Don’t Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if Your Home is in Great Shape 

While there are exceptions to the following rule (e.g. you live out of state and do not want to deal with realtors, showings and buyer contingencies), a home that is in great shape should generally not be offered to a cash buyer.    

I will explain why the above statement is true, but first, to quickly determine if your home qualifies as being “in great shape” as I mean here, run through the questions in the list below.   

If you can answer “yes” to the vast majority of the questions, then personally I do not believe you should be calling a cash buyer.    

Do not trust a cash buyer who says that if you have just one or two of the following issues, you need to sell it to a cash buyer.   

However, if you answer “no” to at least four or five of the following questions, it is worth calling a cash buyer to see if they might be a good fit: 

If You Can Answer Yes to All of These Questions, Do Not Call a Cash Buyer 

  1. Is your basement dry, free of black mold, and free of heavy musty/mold odors? 

  2. Are your basement walls free of significant damage (i.e. they are not bowing, leaning, shearing or cracking)?   

  3. Is your roof leak-free and functioning properly? 

  4. Is your garage concrete pad free of major cracking and damage? 

  5. Are your garage walls and roof in good condition, free of damage and leaks? 

  6. Is your plumbing functional and free of leaks? 

  7. Is your electricity functional and your home free of significant electrical problems? 

  8. Is your home free of intense odors and staining from pets and cigarettes?   

  9. Is your heating and cooling system functional? 

  10. Is your water heater functional?  

  11. Are your floors free of sloping, sagging, softness, or unevenness (i.e. you do not have any potentially serious foundation problems)? 

  12. Your home does not experience sewer backups, slow drains throughout the house, or a failed sewer/septic system? 

  13. There is no visible mold, recurring moisture intrusion, rot, or water damage in walls, ceilings, or floors? 

  14. Your home is free of fire and smoke damage? 

  15. There is no evidence of termites, carpenter ants, rodents, or other pests causing structural or sanitation issues? 

  16. Most of your windows are not broken, rotted, drafty, or non-functioning? Siding is not damaged or rotting? 

  17. There are no significant holes, large cracks, collapsing ceilings, or widespread drywall/plaster damage inside the property? 

  18. The home would not be difficult to insure because of its condition? 

  19. The porches, steps, retaining walls, and chimneys are not cracked, leaning, unsafe, or pulling away from the house? 

  20. There is no heavy clutter, hoarding, stained carpeting, damaged flooring, peeling paint, or generally severe wear that would make showing the home difficult? 

A simpler way to think about this is: Does your home only need cosmetic updates because it is old and dated inside, but it is otherwise ready to live in, or does it require significant investment to make it a functional, safe and livable home?     

If the home requires significant investment to make it livable for a buyer, it is worth it to call a cash buyer.  

Why You Should Not Call a Cash Buyer if Your Ohio Home is in Great Shape 

The answer to this question is incredibly simple.  If your home is in great shape, you will make more money selling it using a realtor.   

Cash buyers are great tools for sellers to use when their home is in bad shape because that is a situation where a cash buyer can add the most value to sellers.  Cash buyers can close really fast, they don’t care about the property’s condition, they won’t ask for any repairs, and they can make competitive offers that will be free of inspection contingencies, financing contingencies, and back-and-forth negotiations.  

Good Ohio cash buyers can do all of that and stay in business because there is a sufficient difference between the value of the home when it is in very bad condition and the value of the home after it is fully renovated.  That difference allows the cash buyer to earn an income.    

If a home is in great shape, typically there is no big difference between its then-current “as-is” value and the value a cash buyer can add to it.  Moreover, the seller who owns a home in great shape can sell it to someone who is going to live in it right away, and that type of buyer (an owner-occupant buyer) can pay more for the home than a cash buyer because that type of buyer does not need to make a profit.   

Don’t Call a Cash Buyer in Ohio if Your Home is Already Listed 

Roughly one out of every five calls I get from potential sellers in Ohio is from a seller whose home is already listed on the market.  The home has been sitting for a long time and either (a) out of general frustration, (b) the belief that their realtor is doing a bad job or (c) misunderstanding why the property has not sold, they decide to call me and see if I will buy it.    

Nine times out of ten I will be telling this seller that they should not be talking to me or any other cash buyers.   

The reasons are simple and are outlined below.   

The Property Listed in Ohio is Subject to a Listing Agreement 

If a home is listed with a realtor, that means the seller has signed a listing agreement.  In simple terms, a listing agreement is a binding contract where the seller agrees to give a realtor a specific amount of time to sell their home and to pay them a commission.

Listing agreements will almost always say that any sale of the home during the time that the agreement is in effect, regardless of who buys it, will result in a commission owed to the realtor.  

When a seller calls me because they are frustrated with their realtor, and they think I can buy it and they will not need to pay a commission, they are wrong.  They will still owe the commission to their realtor unless both (1) the listing agreement has expired and (2) they did not engage with me during the time that their listing agreement was in effect.  That last part is important to keep in mind.  If you sell to a cash buyer who you spoke with during the time your listing agreement was in effect, you may still owe the commission to your former realtor.   

The conversation then moves to my next point, because a seller may be frustrated with their realtor, but the ultimate issue is always the price.   

The Ohio Property is Not Selling Because They Are Asking Too Much 

A lot of the time, in the absence of serious problems with a home, the reason a listed home is not selling is because the price is too high.   

A seller may believe that their realtor has not advertised their home well or had a bad listing strategy, but at the end of the day, if the home has been sitting for a while, there are very few people coming to tour the home and/or those who are touring are not making offers, it is because the asking price is too high.

The harsh reality is that when a seller is already asking too much for their home, and they also have a home that is in good enough condition to be lived in immediately by a buyer, they have no business talking to cash buyers.  They simply need to continue to lower their price until they find a buyer who intends to move into the home.   

In sharp contrast, if the home is completely unlivable, a seller will never be able to find a buyer who wants to live in the home immediately.  They will have much better luck reaching out to an experienced and reliable cash buyer who can make an offer with no inspections, no financing contingencies, and no requests for seller repairs.     

Conclusion: Is a Cash Buyer Right for You?

Whether it makes sense to sell to a cash buyer in Ohio comes down to three things: the condition of your property, your timeline, and how much work you are willing and able to take on.

If your home needs major repairs, is difficult for a buyer to finance, or comes with tenant or long-distance ownership challenges, a cash sale may be worth considering. In those situations, the ability to sell as-is and avoid coordinating repairs, cleanout, and repeated showings can have real value.

On the other hand, if your home is in good condition and you have time to market it, listing with a realtor may leave you with more money. A dated kitchen or frustration with an asking price that has not attracted buyers does not, by itself, make a cash buyer the right solution. Compare what you expect to receive after selling costs with the time, work, and uncertainty each option involves.

If you are still unsure which path makes sense for your Ohio property, I am happy to talk it through with you. You can call or text me at (216) 694-8246 or contact us through LP Property Group. I will give you my honest assessment, including when I think you would be better served by listing your home with a realtor.

Josh Samuel

Josh has been investing in real estate since 2011, and has a passion for understanding the business. From his very first property purchase over a decade ago, which was a great education and the true “school of hard knocks,” Josh, together with his business partner and spouse, Elina, has gone on to successfully purchase numerous properties (both commercial and residential) in multiple markets.

Next
Next

How to Sell a Vacant Home in Northeast OH